Mercedes E63S AMG vs BMW M5 Competition: German Sedan Battle in Montreal

The Mercedes E63S AMG wins on raw power and luxury comfort while the BMW M5 Competition delivers sharper handling and a more connected driving experience, making the E63S ideal for city cruising and the M5 better for spirited driving on Montreal's twisty roads. Both are available for rent at Luxury Car Rental Montreal, and choosing between them comes down to whether you prioritize comfort or driving engagement. ## How Do the Power Numbers Compare Between the E63S and M5? The Mercedes E63S AMG packs a 4.0L twin turbo V8 producing 621 horsepower and 632 lb ft of torque. The BMW M5 Competition counters with a 4.4L twin turbo V8 generating 617 horsepower and 553 lb ft of torque. The E63S holds a clear advantage in torque delivery, giving you that instant shove in the back when you floor it. Both super sedans sprint from 0 to 100 km/h in roughly 3.0 seconds flat. Quarter mile times sit in the mid 11 second range for both cars in stock form. The gap between them is not in the raw numbers. The real difference lives in how each car delivers that power to the pavement. The E63S comes on like a sledgehammer. AMG's 4MATIC+ all wheel drive system channels torque where it is needed most, and the nine speed automatic shifts fast enough to snap your head back. Engage drift mode and the front axle disconnects entirely, letting you roast the rear tires if that is your style. The M5 Competition feels more progressive in its power delivery. BMW's xDrive system works similarly but the power builds in a more linear fashion. You gather speed rather than getting slammed with it. The eight speed ZF automatic is arguably the best torque converter gearbox in any production car today. ## How Do They Handle Montreal Roads? Montreal roads are notoriously rough. Between the potholes on the Decarie Expressway, the frost heaves on Highway 40, and the endless construction zones, you need a performance sedan that can handle terrible pavement without punishing you. The E63S rides on standard air suspension. In Comfort mode, it floats over Montreal's worst surfaces like they do not exist. Switch to Sport+ and the car tightens dramatically, delivering flat and precise body control through corners. The adjustable dampers give you a genuine dual personality car. The M5 Competition uses coil springs with adaptive dampers. It rides firmer than the E63S in Comfort mode, which some drivers actually prefer for the more connected feel. In Sport mode, the M5 communicates everything through the steering wheel. You know exactly what the front tires are doing at all times. For city driving around Old Montreal and the Plateau, the E63S is the more comfortable companion. For attacking the twisty roads up through the Laurentians, the M5 Competition gives you more confidence at the limit. ## Which Interior Is Better for Daily Use? Both cars seat four adults properly. Both offer proper trunk space for luggage. Both feature the technology you expect from six figure German sedans. But their interior philosophies differ significantly. The Mercedes interior is the showpiece here. Dual 12.3 inch screens stretch across the dashboard. The MBUX system responds quickly to inputs, and the Burmester audio system sounds incredible. Materials are top tier throughout, from the Nappa leather to the open pore wood to the aluminum trim. It feels like sitting inside a private jet cabin. BMW takes a more driver focused approach. The M5 interior puts everything around the driver. The M specific seats hold you firmly in place during hard cornering. The head up display projects revs and gear info right into your sightline. It is functional, purposeful, and still luxurious enough for any occasion. If you are picking up clients for dinner at Joe Beef or heading to a business meeting downtown, the E63S makes the stronger impression. If you are driving purely for your own enjoyment, the M5 cockpit feels more natural. ## How Much Does It Cost to Rent the E63S or M5? At Luxury Car Rental Montreal, both the [Mercedes E63S AMG](/mercedes-rental-montreal) and [BMW M5 Competition](/bmw-rental-montreal) are available for daily rental. Rates vary by season and availability, but you can expect pricing to reflect the six figure MSRP of these super sedans. The minimum rental period is 1 day, which equals 24 hours from pickup time. You must be at least 21 years old to rent either car, and full insurance coverage is required. Security deposits range from $1,500 to $10,000 CAD depending on the vehicle and your rental terms. These are serious machines, and the deposit reflects that reality. We deliver anywhere in Greater Montreal, 24 hours a day. Hotel, airport, home, or office, wherever you need the car, we bring it to you. ## Which Super Sedan Should You Rent? If you want maximum comfort paired with absurd power, choose the E63S AMG. The air suspension, the dramatic interior, and the hammer like torque delivery make it the super sedan for people who want luxury first and performance second, even though the performance remains world class. If you want a sharper driving tool, choose the M5 Competition. The steering feel, the chassis balance, and the way it communicates through corners make it the super sedan for people who drive for the sake of driving. Both cars are available now. Check our [FAQ](/faq) for full rental requirements, or browse our [full luxury fleet](/luxury-car-rental-montreal) for more options. ## Can I Rent the E63S or M5 for a Single Day? Yes, the minimum rental period for both the Mercedes E63S AMG and BMW M5 Competition is 1 day, which equals 24 hours. You can extend the rental for additional days at the daily rate. Contact us for multi day pricing as discounts may apply for longer rentals. ## What Are the Age and Insurance Requirements? You must be at least 21 years old to rent either super sedan. Full insurance coverage is required for all rentals. Security deposits range from $1,500 to $10,000 CAD depending on the specific vehicle and rental terms. We handle the insurance paperwork and make the process straightforward. ## Where Can You Deliver the Car? We deliver anywhere in Greater Montreal, 24 hours a day. Whether you need the car at your hotel, at the airport, at your home, or at your office, we bring it to you. Delivery to downtown Montreal, Old Montreal, Westmount, and surrounding areas is included with your rental. ## How Fast Are the E63S and M5 Competition? Both the Mercedes E63S AMG and BMW M5 Competition accelerate from 0 to 100 km/h in approximately 3.0 seconds. The E63S produces 621 horsepower and 632 lb ft of torque while the M5 Competition generates 617 horsepower and 553 lb ft of torque. Quarter mile times for both cars sit in the mid 11 second range in stock form. Ready to settle the Mercedes E63S AMG vs BMW M5 Competition debate for yourself? Stop reading about it and get behind the wheel. Call us at (438) 809-4417 or message us on WhatsApp at wa.me/14388094417. We will have your super sedan delivered wherever you are in Montreal, any time of day.